Pin it
These Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers transform the beloved wing flavor into a wholesome, satisfying meal. Tender bell peppers cradle a creamy, spicy chicken filling that's topped with melted cheese - creating the perfect balance of healthy and indulgent that makes weeknight dinners exciting.
Making these for my family has become a weekly tradition. What started as an attempt to make buffalo wings healthier has become everyone's favorite dinner request. The way the peppers soften while roasting, creating a perfect vessel for the spicy-creamy filling, is simply irresistible.
Essential Ingredients Selection
- Bell Peppers: Choose firm, heavy peppers with glossy skin
- Hot Sauce: Frank's RedHot gives authentic buffalo flavor
- Greek Yogurt: Select full-fat for best creaminess
- Chicken: Rotisserie saves time without sacrificing flavor
- Cheese Blend: Mix sharp and mild for depth of flavor
- Fresh Green Onions: Pick bunches with crisp, bright stalks
Pin it
Detailed Cooking Instructions
- Step 1: Prep Your Peppers (10 minutes)
- Cut lengthwise for stable base. Remove seeds and membranes completely. Pat dry to prevent watery filling. Arrange cut-side up in baking dish.
- Step 2: Create Buffalo Sauce (8 minutes)
- Melt butter slowly to prevent separation. Whisk in hot sauce gradually. Add seasonings in stages. Taste and adjust heat level.
- Step 3: Mix Filling (10 minutes)
- Fold chicken into sauce gently. Add yogurt at room temperature. Stir in cheese while mixture is warm. Season generously.
- Step 4: Stuff and Bake (35 minutes)
- Fill each pepper cavity completely. Top with remaining cheese. Cover loosely with foil. Remove foil last 10 minutes.
- Step 5: Final Touches (5 minutes)
- Let rest briefly before serving. Garnish with fresh green onions. Add optional blue cheese crumbles.
Making it Your Own
This versatile recipe welcomes creative variations:
- Use different pepper colors for visual appeal
- Experiment with cheese combinations
- Adjust spice levels to taste
The first time I made these, I discovered that pre-roasting the peppers slightly before stuffing them creates an even better texture. Now it's my signature twist on the recipe.
Pin it
Mastering Heat Levels
Balance is key for the perfect buffalo flavor:
- Start with less sauce and add more to taste
- Keep extra hot sauce on the table
- Consider mixing mild and spicy peppers
Storage and Reheating Magic
Make these work for busy schedules:
- Prep components separately for quick assembly
- Store filled peppers uncooked for up to 24 hours
- Reheat in oven rather than microwave for best results
My family learned that cutting the peppers lengthwise creates a more stable base for filling. It's these little discoveries that make cooking such a joy.
Pin it
Make-Ahead Strategies
Perfect for busy weeknights:
- Prep filling up to 3 days ahead
- Cut and clean peppers the night before
- Make extra sauce for future meals
This recipe has evolved from a healthy alternative to buffalo wings into a family favorite that even the kids request. It proves that comfort food can be nutritious without sacrificing flavor. The combination of spicy buffalo sauce, creamy filling, and tender peppers creates a meal that's both satisfying and wholesome.
Remember, the key to perfect stuffed peppers is patience - let them bake until the peppers are just tender and the cheese is perfectly melted. Each bite should offer a harmonious blend of spice, creaminess, and fresh pepper flavor.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make these stuffed peppers ahead of time?
- Yes! You can prepare the filling up to 2 days ahead and store it in the fridge. When ready to eat, stuff the peppers and bake as directed.
- → What's the best cheese to use for this recipe?
- Provolone or mozzarella work great for melting, and you can use either feta or blue cheese for topping. Feel free to use a mix of cheeses for more flavor.
- → How spicy are these stuffed peppers?
- Using regular hot sauce makes them medium spicy. You can adjust the heat by using mild sauce or adding more hot sauce to taste.
- → How do you reheat leftover stuffed peppers?
- The best way is to reheat them in the oven at 350°F until heated through. You can also use a microwave, though the peppers might be softer.
- → Can I freeze these stuffed peppers?
- Yes, they freeze well for up to 3 months. Let them thaw overnight in the fridge before reheating in the oven.