Pin it
This New Orleans-style remoulade sauce delivers everything you want from a classic Louisiana condiment - thick, creamy mayonnaise and sour cream base spiked with pungent horseradish, grainy Creole mustard with its distinctive brown mustard seeds and vinegar tang, briny capers that pop in your mouth, sharp fresh garlic, bright parsley and green onions, Louisiana hot sauce for gentle heat, and just enough ketchup to add subtle sweetness and pale pink color that gives "white remoulade" its characteristic blush hue. What makes this sauce so beloved in New Orleans is how it transforms simple fried foods - crispy golden fried shrimp, oysters, catfish, or crab cakes - into something extraordinary through that combination of creamy richness, tangy acidity, spicy heat, herbal brightness, and savory depth that hits multiple flavor receptors simultaneously, creating complexity that plain tartar sauce or cocktail sauce can't match. Pronounced "RAH-muhl-odd" by locals (versus the French "rem-oo-LAHD"), this Cajun-Creole adaptation of French remoulade represents how Louisiana cuisine takes classical French techniques and ingredients, then boldly amplifies them with more garlic, more spice, more personality until they become something distinctly regional that captures the soul of New Orleans cooking - unapologetically flavorful, never bland, always a little bit extra.
The first time making this reveals how transformative proper condiments are - you might assume sauce is just an afterthought, but tasting how remoulade's complex flavors elevate simple fried catfish or shrimp from good to crave-worthy demonstrates that sauces deserve as much attention as the main dish. Watching the pale tan mayonnaise turn pale pink-orange as you stir in the ketchup, mustard, and hot sauce creates visual satisfaction. That first taste where the creamy richness hits first, followed by tangy mustard, then spicy horseradish burn, finishing with herbal brightness from parsley creates understanding of why New Orleanians put this on everything.
Ingredients - What You Need and Why
- Mayonnaise: about one-half cup provides the rich, creamy, emulsified fat base that defines "white remoulade" and creates the thick, coating texture; use quality mayonnaise (Duke's, Hellmann's/Best Foods, or Kewpie) rather than Miracle Whip which is too sweet; the mayo's neutral flavor lets other ingredients shine while providing luxurious mouthfeel and helping other flavors blend smoothly
- Sour cream: about one-half cup is the secret ingredient that elevates this above standard remoulade; the sour cream adds tanginess that mayonnaise lacks, creates even thicker texture that won't run off food, and contributes subtle complexity; this half-and-half ratio creates perfectly balanced richness and tang; you can use all mayo if you must, but the sour cream makes it special
- Creole mustard: about two to three tablespoons provides the signature grainy texture and distinctive flavor; Creole mustard is brown mustard with visible whole seeds, flavored with horseradish and vinegar, creating slightly spicy, tangy, complex character; Zatarain's is the classic Louisiana brand; if unavailable, substitute with Dijon mustard, whole grain mustard, or spicy brown mustard, but avoid plain yellow mustard which is too mild and sweet
- Fresh green onions (scallions): about one-quarter cup finely chopped adds sharp, fresh onion flavor with subtle grassiness; the green and white parts both contribute - white parts are more pungent, green parts add color; chives substitute but are milder; finely mincing is crucial so you don't get large chunks that dominate bites
- Fresh parsley: about two tablespoons finely chopped contributes bright, slightly peppery, herbal notes and beautiful green flecks throughout the pink sauce; Italian flat-leaf parsley has more flavor than curly parsley; fresh is essential - dried parsley tastes like dust
- Fresh garlic: two cloves minced or pressed add pungent, savory depth that mellows after sitting but still provides unmistakable garlic character; fresh garlic tastes dramatically better than jarred minced garlic or garlic powder in raw applications like this where there's no cooking to mellow harshness
- Capers: about one to two tablespoons finely chopped add briny, salty, slightly tangy, olive-like flavor with textural pops; these pickled flower buds provide umami depth and Mediterranean notes; rinse them if they're packed in heavy brine; avoid large capers which are too prominent - small capers (nonpareil) work best
- Prepared horseradish: about one tablespoon adds that signature sinus-clearing, wasabi-like heat that makes your nose tingle; use prepared horseradish from a jar, not fresh horseradish root which requires grating and is extremely intense; adjust quantity based on horseradish strength and your heat tolerance; this is what gives remoulade its distinctive bite
- Ketchup: about one to two tablespoons provides subtle sweetness that balances the tangy, spicy elements while contributing to the characteristic pale pink color; the small amount of tomato adds umami without making it taste like cocktail sauce; use standard ketchup, not fancy artisanal versions with unusual flavors
- Louisiana hot sauce: about one teaspoon (or to taste) adds vinegary heat and that essential Louisiana character; use thin, vinegar-based Louisiana hot sauce like Crystal, Louisiana Brand, or Tabasco rather than thick hot sauces like sriracha; the vinegar component is crucial for proper tanginess; adjust based on desired heat level
- Salt and black pepper: to taste for final seasoning; start with one-quarter teaspoon each and adjust after tasting; the capers and hot sauce provide salt, so you may need less than expected
How to Make Remoulade Sauce - Step by Step
- Prepare all the fresh ingredients:
- Begin by gathering and preparing all your fresh components, which is the only real work in this recipe. Take your bunch of green onions and rinse them under cold water to remove any dirt or grit. Pat them dry with paper towels. Trim off the root ends and any wilted or slimy parts from the green tops. Now finely chop both the white and green parts - you want pieces about the size of a grain of rice, not large chunks. You should end up with about one-quarter cup of finely chopped green onions. Transfer these to a medium mixing bowl. Rinse your fresh parsley and pat it completely dry (wet herbs don't chop well). Remove the leaves from the thick stems, then gather them into a tight bunch on your cutting board. Using a sharp chef's knife, mince the parsley as finely as possible - rock the knife back and forth, periodically gathering the spreading herbs back into a pile. You want about two tablespoons of finely minced parsley with no large pieces. Add this to the bowl with the green onions. Peel two garlic cloves and either mince them extremely finely with a knife or push them through a garlic press. The finer the garlic, the better it distributes and the less raw-garlic bite you'll get. Add the garlic to the bowl. Finally, drain and rinse your capers. Place them on your cutting board and chop them finely - you don't need paste, just small pieces so you get capers in every bite without overwhelming chunks. Add about one to two tablespoons to the bowl.
- Combine all sauce ingredients:
- Now that your fresh ingredients are prepped and in the bowl, add all the remaining ingredients. Spoon in one-half cup of mayonnaise - don't pack the measuring cup; just scoop and level it off. Add one-half cup of sour cream using the same measuring technique. Spoon in two to three tablespoons of Creole mustard - start with two tablespoons if you're unsure, as you can always add more but can't remove it. Add one tablespoon of prepared horseradish, squeezing out excess liquid before measuring. Spoon in one to two tablespoons of ketchup - one tablespoon for subtle sweetness and pale color, two for more pronounced sweetness and pinker hue. Add about one teaspoon of Louisiana hot sauce, or more if you like heat. Finally, add about one-quarter teaspoon each of salt and freshly ground black pepper. Now use a rubber spatula, wooden spoon, or whisk to stir everything together thoroughly. Mix vigorously for about one minute, scraping down the sides and bottom of the bowl to ensure all ingredients are completely incorporated. The sauce should be thick, creamy, and uniform pale pink-orange color with visible green flecks of herbs and brown mustard seeds throughout. Taste carefully - it should be tangy, creamy, slightly spicy from the horseradish and hot sauce, savory from the garlic, with subtle sweetness balancing everything. Adjust seasoning as needed: add more salt if it tastes flat, more hot sauce for heat, more mustard for tang, more ketchup for sweetness, or more horseradish for that sinus-clearing bite.
- Chill and serve:
- This is crucial and often overlooked: don't serve the remoulade immediately after making it. Transfer the sauce to an airtight container or keep it in the mixing bowl and cover tightly with plastic wrap. Refrigerate for at least thirty minutes before serving, though one hour is better and overnight is ideal. This chilling time allows several important things to happen: the raw garlic mellows significantly, losing its harsh bite while retaining its savory depth; all the flavors meld and marry, creating unified complexity rather than distinct separate tastes; the sauce thickens further as it chills; and the fresh herbs infuse throughout rather than tasting like separate elements. After chilling, give the sauce a quick stir before serving as some separation may occur. The remoulade is now ready to serve as a dipping sauce, sandwich spread, or salad dressing. If using as salad dressing, thin it with a tablespoon or two of water, milk, or buttermilk to reach pourable consistency. Serve cold - never heat remoulade as the mayonnaise will break and separate. Store any leftovers covered in the refrigerator for four to five days. The flavor actually improves over the first day or two, making this an excellent make-ahead condiment.
Pin it
Understanding that remoulade belongs to the family of French mother sauces (specifically mayonnaise-based sauces) helps you see its connection to tartar sauce, aioli, and other mayonnaise derivatives, while recognizing how Louisiana cooks took the French concept and made it bolder and spicier.
Understanding New Orleans Remoulade Traditions
Remoulade sauce represents one of the clearest examples of how New Orleans cuisine adapted French culinary traditions to create something distinctly Creole. Classical French remoulade, as taught in culinary schools, is a refined mayonnaise-based sauce with capers, cornichons (tiny pickles), herbs, and anchovies - elegant and restrained. When this sauce arrived in Louisiana through French colonization, local cooks transformed it by amplifying flavors dramatically: more garlic, addition of horseradish (not traditional in France), Louisiana hot sauce, Creole mustard with its grainy texture, and bold seasoning that would shock French chefs. This pattern of taking French techniques and "Creolizing" them with bolder flavors, more spice, and local ingredients defines Louisiana cooking. The division between "white remoulade" (mayonnaise-based) and "red remoulade" (oil-and-vinegar-based with ketchup or tomato) shows further evolution - the red version was popularized by Arnaud's restaurant in the French Quarter through their famous Shrimp Arnaud dish served with red remoulade. Each New Orleans family guards their own remoulade recipe with variations in spice level, mustard type, and ingredients, but all share that characteristic Louisiana boldness that makes them more intense than their French ancestor.
Creating Flavor Variations and Regional Styles
While the classic New Orleans remoulade is delicious as written, exploring variations showcases the sauce's versatility while maintaining the fundamental creamy-tangy-spicy character. For traditional red remoulade (Arnaud's style), replace the mayonnaise and sour cream base with three-quarters cup olive oil, one-quarter cup red wine vinegar, two tablespoons tomato paste or ketchup, and whisk in the same Creole mustard, garlic, capers, and seasonings, creating oil-and-vinegar emulsion instead of mayo-based sauce that's tangier and lighter. Spicy remoulade increases hot sauce to two to three tablespoons and adds one-quarter teaspoon cayenne pepper for serious heat lovers. Lemon-herb version incorporates two tablespoons of fresh lemon juice and zest of one lemon plus additional fresh herbs like dill, tarragon, or chives for brighter, more herbaceous character. Pickle remoulade adds two tablespoons of finely diced dill pickles for extra crunch and tang. Smoky remoulade includes one teaspoon of smoked paprika and a few drops of liquid smoke for barbecue-friendly version. Dijon remoulade substitutes smooth Dijon mustard for grainy Creole mustard, creating more refined, French-leaning sauce. Cajun remoulade adds one tablespoon of Cajun seasoning for more complex spice blend. Old Bay remoulade incorporates two teaspoons of Old Bay seasoning for Mid-Atlantic crab house flavor. Each variation maintains the creamy base while exploring different regional or personal flavor directions.
Troubleshooting Common Sauce Problems
Even with straightforward mixing, sometimes remoulade doesn't turn out perfectly, but understanding what went wrong helps you prevent issues next time. If the sauce is too thin and runny rather than thick and coating, you either used low-fat mayonnaise or sour cream, measured ingredients incorrectly, or added too much liquid from wet capers or pickle juice - drain ingredients well and use full-fat mayo and sour cream for proper thickness, or stir in additional mayo to thicken. When the sauce tastes too sharp and harsh rather than balanced, the raw garlic is overpowering - you either used too much, didn't mince it finely enough (large chunks are more pungent), or didn't let it chill long enough to mellow; refrigerate overnight and the harshness will dissipate significantly. If remoulade tastes flat and bland rather than bold and flavorful, you either under-seasoned, used low-quality or expired spices, or didn't use enough of the key ingredients like mustard, horseradish, and hot sauce - taste and aggressively adjust seasoning, and always use fresh, quality ingredients. Sauce that's too spicy and burns rather than having pleasant heat means too much horseradish or hot sauce - balance by stirring in additional mayonnaise and sour cream to dilute, plus a touch more ketchup for sweetness. When the sauce separates with liquid pooling on top, this indicates the mayo or sour cream was old and breaking down, or you somehow introduced heat - always use fresh dairy products and keep everything cold. Remoulade with large chunks that don't blend smoothly means you didn't chop ingredients finely enough - take time to properly mince everything to rice-grain size.
Complete Meal Planning and Classic Louisiana Pairings
Understanding traditional New Orleans applications helps you integrate remoulade authentically into meals rather than just using it randomly. For classic seafood preparations, serve remoulade as the primary sauce for fried shrimp, fried oysters, fried catfish, soft-shell crab, or crab cakes - the creamy, tangy sauce cuts through fried foods' richness while complementing seafood's delicate flavor. In po' boy sandwiches, spread remoulade on both sides of French bread, then pile with fried shrimp, dressed (lettuce, tomato, pickles), creating the classic shrimp po' boy. Roast beef po' boys also use remoulade instead of mayonnaise. For boiled seafood, make shrimp remoulade appetizer by tossing boiled, peeled shrimp with remoulade and serving over shredded lettuce with lemon wedges - this classic New Orleans restaurant appetizer showcases how the sauce works cold. With crab, serve remoulade alongside lump crab meat, crab cakes, or stuffed crab. For complete Louisiana meal, serve fried catfish with remoulade, coleslaw, hush puppies, and french fries. Oyster po' boys need remoulade, lettuce, tomato, and pickles. As party dip, serve remoulade in a bowl surrounded by fried appetizers - catfish bites, shrimp, oysters, fried green tomatoes, onion rings. Beyond seafood, remoulade works on fried chicken tenders, as burger spread, mixed into potato salad or pasta salad, or as vegetable dip for raw carrots, celery, and bell peppers.
Storage Guidelines and Food Safety Considerations
Understanding proper storage ensures food safety and maximum quality for your homemade remoulade. Store the sauce in an airtight container - glass jars, plastic containers with tight-fitting lids, or squeeze bottles all work well. Always refrigerate immediately after making and keep at 40°F or below. The sauce keeps safely for four to five days refrigerated, though quality begins declining after three days as the fresh herbs lose brightness and the garlic becomes more pungent. Beyond five days, risk of bacterial growth increases due to the raw garlic and fresh herbs, plus the mayonnaise can begin breaking down. Never leave remoulade at room temperature longer than two hours (one hour if outdoor temperature exceeds 90°F) as mayonnaise-based sauces are ideal environments for bacteria growth. When serving buffet-style, keep the remoulade bowl nested in a larger bowl of ice to maintain cold temperature. Always use clean utensils when scooping sauce - never double-dip or use utensils that touched raw food. If sauce develops off smell, unusual color, mold, or separation, discard it immediately. For meal prep, portion remoulade into small containers with individual servings rather than one large container you dip into repeatedly, reducing contamination risk. The sauce cannot be frozen as mayonnaise's emulsion breaks during freezing and thawing, creating separated, watery, unusable mess.
The Science of Emulsions and Why Mayo Works
Understanding the chemistry of mayonnaise-based sauces helps explain why certain techniques matter and how to prevent problems. Mayonnaise is an emulsion - tiny droplets of oil suspended in water (from eggs and vinegar), stabilized by lecithin in egg yolks acting as emulsifier. This stable emulsion provides the base that allows other ingredients to blend smoothly rather than separating. When you add ingredients like mustard (which contains its own emulsifiers), horseradish, and sour cream to mayonnaise, they integrate into the existing emulsion rather than separating. The sour cream's additional fat and protein strengthen the emulsion while its acidity (from lactic acid) helps maintain stability. The thick, coating texture comes from the emulsion's structure - millions of oil droplets create viscosity that coats food rather than running off like thin liquids. Temperature affects emulsions significantly - cold stabilizes them (which is why remoulade must stay refrigerated), while heat breaks them as proteins denature and the oil droplets coalesce. Understanding these principles explains why you can't freeze mayo-based sauces (freezing disrupts the emulsion structure), why they must stay cold (warmth breaks emulsification), and why adding too much liquid can thin them (dilutes the oil-to-water ratio that creates thickness).
Teaching Sauce-Making Fundamentals and Knife Skills
This recipe provides excellent opportunity to learn basic culinary skills that transfer to countless other preparations. Proper knife skills for mincing herbs and aromatics represent fundamental technique - learning to hold the knife correctly, using a rocking motion, and gathering scattered ingredients back into a pile teaches efficiency that applies to all cooking. Understanding how to taste and adjust seasoning teaches you to trust your palate rather than blindly following measurements - recognizing when something needs more salt, acid, heat, or sweetness builds cooking intuition. The concept of letting flavors meld demonstrates that timing matters even in no-cook recipes - patience improves results. Learning to balance flavors - richness from mayo and sour cream, acidity from mustard and vinegar, heat from horseradish and hot sauce, sweetness from ketchup - teaches fundamental flavor theory applicable across cuisines. Understanding mise en place (having everything prepped before combining) builds efficient work habits. For beginners intimidated by sauce-making, this recipe builds tremendous confidence because it's nearly foolproof - no emulsifying eggs, no reducing liquids, no precise temperatures - just chopping and mixing. Success encourages trying more ambitious sauces like hollandaise, béarnaise, or from-scratch mayonnaise.
The Economics of Homemade Versus Store-Bought
Understanding cost comparisons between homemade and commercial remoulade reveals modest savings but dramatic quality improvements. The ingredients - mayonnaise (three dollars), sour cream (two dollars), Creole mustard (four dollars but you use a tiny portion), fresh herbs and aromatics (three dollars), condiments (pennies) - total approximately five to eight dollars for about one and a half cups of remoulade, or roughly four to five dollars per cup. Store-bought Louisiana remoulade from specialty brands costs six to ten dollars per cup, with limited availability outside the South. Beyond modest monetary savings, homemade offers complete control over quality, spice level, and ingredients. You can use organic mayonnaise, adjust garlic to preference, and make it as spicy or mild as desired. The freshness of homemade far exceeds bottled versions which often contain preservatives and lack the bright herb flavor. Restaurant remoulade costs nothing when dining out (it's included with dishes), but making it at home allows you to recreate restaurant experiences without dining out. For people living outside Louisiana where authentic remoulade is unavailable, homemade becomes the only way to enjoy this regional specialty. The satisfaction of creating authentic New Orleans condiment from scratch adds value beyond cost, especially when serving to guests who recognize and appreciate quality remoulade.
Cultural Context and Creole Culinary Heritage
Understanding remoulade's place in New Orleans cuisine helps appreciate its cultural significance beyond just being tasty sauce. The sauce represents Creole cooking's fundamental character - taking European (specifically French) culinary foundations and transforming them with African, Spanish, Caribbean, and Native American influences to create something entirely new. This cultural fusion defines New Orleans food culture where nothing remains purely one ethnicity but instead becomes "Creole" - blended, adapted, and distinctly local. Remoulade appears in both Creole (city-based, more refined) and Cajun (country-based, more rustic) cooking traditions, though with different emphases. The sauce's prominence in New Orleans restaurants from fine dining establishments to casual po' boy shops demonstrates its democratic appeal crossing class boundaries. Understanding terms like "dressed" (lettuce, tomato, pickles on sandwiches) and "po' boy" (submarine sandwich on French bread) helps you speak the local food language. For people with New Orleans heritage, making authentic remoulade connects them to cultural identity and childhood memories. For outsiders, learning to make it represents respectful engagement with regional cuisine, appreciating its complexity and significance rather than treating it as just another sauce recipe.
Pin it
This New Orleans-style remoulade sauce represents the perfect intersection of French culinary refinement and Louisiana boldness, proving that regional American sauces deserve equal respect to their European ancestors when they transform borrowed techniques into something distinctly local and delicious. What makes this recipe genuinely valuable is how it teaches fundamental sauce-making principles - balancing richness with acid, building complexity through layering ingredients, understanding how flavors meld over time - through an accessible preparation requiring no special skills or equipment beyond basic knife work and mixing. The transformation of simple commercial ingredients - mayonnaise, sour cream, and pantry staples - into something that tastes authentically New Orleans and rivals any restaurant version demonstrates that impressive results come from understanding proper ingredient ratios and flavor balance rather than exotic components or complicated techniques. Whether you're a Louisiana native wanting to recreate childhood flavors, someone who visited New Orleans and fell in love with the food, a seafood enthusiast seeking the perfect accompaniment for fried shrimp or crab cakes, or simply a sauce lover who appreciates bold, complex condiments that elevate everything they touch, this delivers completely. The versatility means one batch serves multiple purposes throughout the week - Monday's fried fish dinner, Wednesday's shrimp po' boy lunch, Friday's crudité platter for guests - making the ten-minute preparation investment pay dividends across multiple meals. Once you've experienced how this creamy, tangy, spicy, herby sauce transforms simple fried catfish into something special, or elevated a basic sandwich into po' boy excellence, and tasted how the flavors deepen and improve after sitting overnight in the refrigerator, you'll find yourself making batch after batch, experimenting with spice levels and variations, keeping it constantly in your refrigerator alongside ketchup and mustard because it's simply that useful and delicious, and understanding why New Orleanians consider remoulade an essential condiment rather than optional garnish, proudly sharing your homemade version with guests who inevitably ask for the recipe after trying it.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What does remoulade sauce taste like?
- It's tangy, creamy, and has a nice kick from the horseradish and hot sauce. Think of it as a spiced-up mayo with mustard and herbs mixed in.
- → Can I make this sauce ahead of time?
- Yes! Actually, it tastes even better when you make it a day or two before you need it. The flavors get better as they sit together in the fridge.
- → What can I use remoulade sauce on?
- It's great on fried shrimp, fish, crab cakes, po'boy sandwiches, burgers, or as a dip for vegetables. You can even use it as a salad dressing.
- → How long does homemade remoulade last?
- Keep it in a sealed container in your fridge and it'll stay fresh for 4 to 5 days. Don't freeze it though - mayo doesn't handle freezing well.
- → Can I make this sauce less spicy?
- Sure! Just use less hot sauce or skip the horseradish. You can always start with a little and add more if you want it spicier.
- → What's the difference between remoulade and tartar sauce?
- Remoulade has more spices and heat - it includes mustard, hot sauce, and horseradish. Tartar sauce is milder with pickles and relish instead.